| 
    STAGE 
   | 
  
    BASIC 
   | 
  
    AVERAGE 
   | 
  
    IDEAL 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   1) Data Sources 
   | 
  
   Knowledge in the  
  heads  of individuals. 
    
   | 
  
   Top 20 Applications known
  with list of Data Sources and Owners 
   | 
  
   Agile
  development with refactoring techniques. 
    
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
   No Data
  Models and poor documentation of links between code and databases. 
   | 
  
   Basic Data
  Dictionary in place. 
   | 
  
   Data Models and sign-off by
  DBA on all changes. 
    
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
   User access and sign-off for
  Data Dictionary 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   2) Data Integration 
   | 
  
   Ad-hoc integration using
  bespoke SQL Scripts 
   | 
  
   Some Templates established
  and commercial Tools in use. 
   | 
  
   MDM approved, data owner
  sign-off, 
  Data Quality is an Enterprise issue. 
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
   Software Tools linked to the
  Data Dictionary 
   | 
  
   Clear and
  reconciled top-down and bottom-up views of data. 
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
   Data
  Architecture and Data Models for Sources and Targets.  
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
   Nobody understands Master
  Data Management (MDM) 
   | 
  
   MDM is planned 
   | 
  
   MDM is in place 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   2) Data Quality - 
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
  | 
       DQ level -  
   | 
  
   Could be improved 
   | 
  
   Sufficient 
   | 
  
   Accurate, valid and relevant 
   | 
 
 
  | 
       Policy - 
   | 
  
   Under consideration 
   | 
  
   Under implementation 
   | 
  
   Established as Enterprise Issue 
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
 
 
  | 
   3) Performance 
  Rpts 
   | 
  
   One-off, often independent
  Dept. Spreadsheets   
   | 
  
   Independent Maps, KPIs and drill-down to detailed Reports 
   | 
  
   Integrated Maps, KPIs and drill-downs for Chief Exec 
   | 
 
 
  | 
   4) Internet Mashups 
   | 
  
   None 
   | 
  
   Isolated development 
   | 
  
   Users aware  
   | 
 
 
  | 
   5) Data Governance 
   | 
  
   None 
   | 
  
   No
  end-to-end agreement. 
   | 
  
   Procedures published, Roles
  and Responsibilities and Sign-off all in place. 
   | 
 
 
  | 
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
     
   | 
  
   Data
  lineage known and auditable. 
   |